Can a Good Writer Become Great?

Here’s a question: Can a good writer become great?

Stephen King says no:

“While it is impossible to make a competent writer out of a bad writer, and while it is equally impossible to make a great writer out of a good one, it is possible, with lots of hard work, dedication, and timely help, to make a good writer out of a merely competent one.”

If he’s right, then I am utterly demoralised. Does that mean I’ll never be any better than I am? Is there no point in even striving towards excellence? Should I settle for the status quo and never reach for the next level?

I think if I believed that, I’d have to quit right now. Striving always to be better, to reach the next level, is part of being an artist. Succeeding is not as important as trying. The only real failure is giving up. Yes, those words sound like lines you’d hear in a sports movie made for kids, but that doesn’t mean they’re not true.

When I started working seriously at my writing, I stuck with it. I read everything I could on crafting a story. I attended lectures. I rewrote pieces incessantly. I read. And I read. And I read. I was able to weather the inevitable rejections and the hard work because deep down I knew I was a writer. I knew if I persevered I would succeed.

If success means publication, then yes, I have met that goal. But is that a reliable standard? Who decides what is bad or good or excellent?

If you’re just starting out as a writer and if you’ve never been published, then you may believe as I once did that publication is a reasonable measure of excellence. After all, it says that someone other than your best friend and your family rates what you’re doing. But think about it. Aren’t we assuming that just because someone is an editor or a publisher they must have excellent taste–especially if they decide to publish our own work? Yet we have all heard the tales of extraordinary works of literature being rejected over and over until someone saw their merit. By the same token, we can all name at least fifty shades… uh, examples of stuff that should never have seen the light of day being published.

So much for publication being proof of anything.

Literature is strewn with the wreckage of those who have minded beyond reason the opinion of others. Virginia Woolfe.

Why should I care what King thinks? He cannot speak for me. I’m the only one who can know if I’m reaching the standards I set for myself.However, it would be foolish to deny that greatness is very rare. Is it inherent or can it be earned? I don’t know. I’d like to think that a good writer, if she works hard enough, can on occasion produce work that is on another level. Maybe not with the frequency of, say, a John Steinbeck, but at least once in a career.

So, how do you do that?

Willa Cather, author of O, Pioneers! and My Antonia, started her writing career as a journalist. The work was demanding but lucrative. Her friend, the novelist and short story writer Sarah Orne Jewett, advised her to forgo journalism in favour of literature. “Your vivid, exciting companionship in the office must not be your audience,” she wrote. “You must find your own quiet centre of life, and write from that to the world that holds offices, and all society, all Bohemia; the city, the country—in short, you must write to the human heart, the great consciousness that all humanity goes to make up… We must be ourselves, but we must be our best selves.”

There seems little doubt that Cather was an inherently gifted literary novelist. But how can the writer know if he or she has the same essential gift?

I am, I think, a good writer. But where I fall short is I have spent too much time focusing on the craft of writing rather than the art. Like any literary student, I can examine a piece of prose and tell you exactly why it works–or doesn’t. But while such analysis has merit, it isn’t the same thing as producing original and insightful work of one’s own.

“Technique holds a reader from sentence to sentence, but only content will stay in his mind.” ― Joyce Carol Oates

Then again, it’s only by analysing great writing and determining why it’s great that we can grow. We read the greats, determine why they are great, and apply as many of those lessons to our own work as possible.

Writers have to be willing to fail and fail repeatedly. We have to be willing to study our art even when we have become successful. We must keep on striving and we must believe that greatness can be within our grasp if we stretch ourselves far enough.

When I started writing in the 1800s (it seems like), I was bad. I mean pee-ooh! bad. By dint of hard work and determination I’ve become pretty good. Great? Well, it’s early days yet. A few more years of frustration, sleepless nights, and hard work and I may get there. The point is, if I can get from bad to good, why can’t I get from good to great?

So, if it’s such hard work, why bother? If you’ve been a decent, even half-way successful writer at one level, why would you try to get up onto the next step, knowing how hard it is? Because we cannot help ourselves. Because striving for more is part of an artist’s DNA. Dorothy L Sayers could have rested on her Lord Peter Wimsey laurels, but she chose to write serious essays about religion and to translate Dante. Stephen King tried to write serious fiction, but couldn’t get it taken seriously by the critics. Hell, even Paul McCartney wrote an oratorio.

The purpose of literature, TS Eliot said, is to turn blood into ink. Is it painful? Very. Challenging? Indeed. Yet we cannot help ourselves.

What do you think? Can a writer transition from bad to good, and from good to great? Why do we keep trying? Let me know in the comments.




About Geri Schear

Geri Schear is an award-winning novelist, author of three Sherlock Holmes and Lady Beatrice books published by MX Publishing. Her short stories have appeared in a number of journals. For further information, see her page at Amazon:
This entry was posted in Writing and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Can a Good Writer Become Great?

  1. pberinstein says:

    I haven’t been able to get this post out of my head, Geri. The question is something I think about a lot. I do think a good writer can become great, but it takes an enormous amount of dedication and motivation. Great writing grows out of a unique way of looking at the world. Great writers see things other people don’t, approach the world with a different attitude. Most people who stand out in that way are born that way. He wasn’t a writer, but Robin Williams comes to mind. He just always saw the edges in the world. That’s what great writers do too.

    I think in order to become great, you have to learn to see the world in new ways. We aren’t wired to do this, so it’s supremely difficult. Most people don’t even try. But those few who do–and work at it consistently–will be rewarded, IMO.

    Liked by 1 person

    • rycardus says:

      Thanks for such an insightful reply. Yes, Robin Williams is a great example. His world view was unique and wonderful in equal measures. He did what great writers and other creatives do: he showed us the world in a completely new way. I think by dint of continuous effort, hard work, and exposure to the work of such visionaries, we can exceed our own innate abilities. I hope so, anyway.

      Liked by 1 person

      • pberinstein says:

        It would be interesting to try this, I think–put together a list of things to do and see how it works out. Have you done something like that?

        Liked by 1 person

  2. rycardus says:

    I’ve been doing a variety of things. The last short story I wrote I took a completely immersive approach. It’s set in NY in the 1960s and I watched documentaries and listened to music that fit the mood of the piece. I wrote it with three narrators and a fragmented timeline, something I haven’t tried before. I think it’s one of the best things I’ve written and feedback has been excellent. I’m also re-reading a lot of contemporary short fiction and analysing what I like and trying to figure out what I can bring to my own work. Finally, I’ve been devouring the articles on this site about literary writing: What about you? What have you been trying?

    Liked by 1 person

    • pberinstein says:

      Oooh, I’d love to read that. May I? It sounds amazing!

      I haven’t been taking a systematic approach to learning to see the world in new ways, but I do do a variety of things rather randomly. One of the things I’ve been thinking about for some time is how people who are different from the mainstream experience the world. I have a blind character in my books, and a deaf one, and now one is in a wheelchair. I am working on an idea for a new series that includes another person who is different. I spend a fair amount of time trying to imagine what it would be like to experience the world as they do.

      I also try to step into various characters to see if I can identify with them even if I’m nothing like them. (I am a terrible actor but I find this interesting anyway.) I find this quite difficult. I have no desire to be a “villain,” for instance, and find it hard to empathize. But I keep trying.

      I’ve also been reading books outside my comfort zone. I’m struggling with A River Runs Through It right now–it’s got a lot about fishing in it, which is not one of my interests–and I’ve been trying to read fantasy and paranormal stories. They’re hard too. I find all that world-building gets in the way of the story if the author isn’t careful. When I get tired I go back to good old mysteries, which soothe my mind. 🙂 I’m thinking of going back to some of the books I read in college too, like The Red and the Black and The Sorrows of Young Werther and that sort of thing. I hope I can hack it. I don’t have as much patience as I did back then. I suspect I won’t find them easy reading.

      But I think it takes more than all of that to learn to look at the world differently. It takes trying to be the people who do that, see what it’s like to be inside their heads, like Robin Williams and David Bowie and Alan Ball (TV writer who wrote “Six Feet Under” and other stuff, and Carlos Ruiz Zafon, a most amazing writer I’ve recently discovered, and Emily Dickinson and Tana French. And that is really, really hard.


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.