Are You a Professional Writer?

The other day I approached the Irish Writers’ Centre with an idea for a class. They were very enthusiastic about the suggestion and, over the course of a few e-mails, asked if I’d consider applying for professional membership of the centre.

Yes, I thought, I would. Off I trotted, metaphorically, to the website and checked out the requirements. They’re here, if you’re interested:

I discovered that the centre has a set of criteria, eleven in all, of which the applicant must have met three. These include things such as having a book published, a play produced, or winning a prize. In other words, the hallmarks of the professional writer.

The list got me thinking about how we, as writers, measure professional status.

The dictionary defines ‘professional’ as “relating to or belonging to a profession… engaged in specified activity as one’s main paid occupation rather than an amateur… a person engaged or qualified in a profession.”

In order to become a nurse I had to train for three years, master a series of practical tests, and pass a final exam. Once that was accomplished, I was given my diploma and the right to call myself a professional nurse.

The criteria for becoming a professional writer is a bit of a breech birth: You don’t get professional status first and then become a writer. No, you start writing and, with hard work and a lot of luck, pass a number of milestones along the way. If you pass enough of these milestones, or just one very big one, you can probably call yourself a professional writer.

Now, I bet I can guess what you’re thinking: Why do I need a list? Surely I can call myself a professional writer if I’ve written something and had it published? That sounds rational enough, but let’s examine it.

What do you need to have published? Can it be a letter to the editor of your local newspaper? You wrote it, they published it; that makes you a professional. Right?

OK, I think we can agree that probably doesn’t meet the criteria. After all, my friend Jane can put a Band-Aid on her finger, but that doesn’t make her a health care professional. What if you write a blog? If you post it on-line, you’re technically publishing. Does that make you a professional? You see, it’s a tricky subject.

We can’t even consider payment a solid foundation. An article in Forbes had this to say:

It’s well known that author advances are dwindling and, at the same time, a whole new model of publishing is allowing a lot of people to write and earn money without going through traditional processes. But for both types of author, it’s an annoying fact that very, very few earn enough to give up all other kinds of work. Whether you’re a published author who got a couple of grand for your debut novel or a self-published author who earns tens or a few hundreds of pounds a month for your work, you’re basically in the same boat, having to keep a job or other source of income in order to make ends meet. If having a job means you’re not a professional, then most authors aren’t professionals.  Suw Charman-Anderson, Forbes Magazine 8/7/13

Ah, there’s nothing like a nice bucket of cold water in the face on a Wednesday afternoon.

Sadly, though, the Forbes’ author is right. In this age of self-publishing, finding some mutually acceptable set of criteria is extremely difficult. Is someone less of a professional because they handle the publication side of things themselves, rather than take the traditional route?

If you enter the words ‘professional writer’ into the internet, that nexus of knowledge — well, some knowledge and a lot of faecal matter — throws up (in every sense of the phrase) any number of classes designed to help you become a ‘professional writer’. The people advertising these classes don’t explain how they are defining the term ‘professional’, though they seem pretty clear about how much attending their classes will cost you.

Let’s try another tack. Perhaps we can get to a definition of professional by applying the standards of professionalism.

To behave in a professional manner, the writer consistently produces a high standard of work. We expect this as the norm from other professionals. Who wants a slapdash doctor? A professional writer will take pains over her work and do so consistently. The amateur may reach excellence some of the time, or never, depending on their experience and willingness to master their craft.

The professional meets deadlines, sets goals and revises them as necessary. He keeps up with industry news and developments, and takes classes to hone his skills. Here’s a question for you writers out there: when did you last look up the status of publishing in your country? Here’s another question: Do you even know how to find that information? Here’s a hint, do an internet search for ‘publishing’ followed by the name of your country. At the very least, you should be familiar with Publisher’s Weekly:  It’s an American site, but they cover international news, too.

Behaving professionally means being accountable for your work. That means you do the research, you get your facts right, or as right as you can. You sign your work with your name. If you make an error you admit it. And you never, ever, ever steal from another writer.

Finally, I’d suggest that one of the most fundamental standards is how we are perceived by our peers. If other writers consider us professionals; if our work is being published in literary journals alongside people we admire; if we are winning prizes that define our work as excellent, then I think we can consider ourselves professionals. More to the point, other people will do so, too.

I'm a Professional


About Geri Schear

Geri Schear is an award-winning novelist, author of three Sherlock Holmes and Lady Beatrice books published by MX Publishing. Her short stories have appeared in a number of journals. For further information, see her page at Amazon:
This entry was posted in Writing and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Are You a Professional Writer?

  1. Cara Schear says:

    I think the concept of a professional writer is ambiguous. It’s actually a hard thing to tie down in any one sense.
    When I think of a professional person, I conjure an image of a person in a suit, making money from their chosen profession. However, couldn’t we also see it as a person working at their profession? Wouldn’t that make them a “professional?”
    Aren’t there things we’re all professionally good at? Can’t you be professionally good at typing as an office worker, yet you might spend more time typing things into Google?
    The ambiguity of the term “professional” is what makes it an interesting topic.
    Personally, I find the definition to lie at this: a professional writer is someone who takes pleasure in writing, and makes attempts to get better at their craft on a regular basis.
    I think the concept of having to have published or produced something of value to an agent, publisher, or a film studio/theatre is a degree of success that has little to do with being professional.


    • rycardus says:

      I agree it’s an interesting topic.. More to the point, it’s a very tricky one. It’s a bit like asking five rabbis for an answer — you’ll surely get six different replies.

      I’m not sure I agree that merely taking pleasure in writing and attempting to be good at it warrants professional status, at least, not on its own. You can aspire to be the best fisherman ever, read up about the types of bait and best equipment, but just because you catch the occasional salmon, that doesn’t make you a professional. On the other hand, you won’t ever become a professional until you do work hard at reaching a standard of excellence.

      Right now, writing is being swamped by people of varying degrees of talent who call themselves professional writers, but I’m sure you’d agree there’s a vast gulf between someone who posts the occasional blog and a Booker Prize-winner.


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.